If you’re ever unsure of the
intelligence of the average human, go check out the comments section of any
article on Yahoo or video posted to YouTube. It’s like the internet has given
people the necessary anonymity to say whatever dumb thing pops into their
little minds. Sadly, the same thing is true for book reviews.
Everyone who’s ever read a book is
now an expert on writing, thanks to the ability to post reviews on the online
sales pages of books. Whether you actually read the book cover-to-cover or if
you just walked by the display in your local bookstore, you’re now able to
write your comments for all the internet to see.
In the interest of full disclosure,
here is the most aggravating review of my own book on autism:
“This book was okay if your child is
younger. My son was diagnosed at age six and I had already put into place most
of the practices discussed and was past other stages. If your child is older
than 2, I recommend books by Ellen Notbohm and Paula Kluth instead.”
Let’s dissect this: first of all,
her child is older than my child. HOW WAS THAT MY FAULT? You gave this book a
3-star review, thus dropping its status, because you squeezed your kid out
before I did? Then you proceeded to completely shanghai my Amazon page with a
COMMERCIAL FOR A DIFFERENT BOOK. That’s like me going to the Amazon page for
THE HOLY BIBLE and writing, “Y’all should totally read The Torah, it’s way
better.”
Now, I realize this sounds like me
just venting some anger at a pointless review. Let me be the first to assure
you that it’s not the case. I have two UGLY one-star reviews from people who
absolutely hated my book and I respect them for having strong feelings about a
topic and trying to share those feelings with others. I don’t like what they
had to say, obviously, but I respect their opinions. This crappy review above,
however, was just unnecessary.
As readers, we should make our
points clearly and succinctly. I agree that having forked over some of my
hard-earned cash to purchase a book does give me some right to voice an opinion
on it. But as writers, we should stick to an honest evaluation of the writing
in a book we review. I can read a book on a topic I don’t really care about but
still be able to intelligently appraise the book’s value. I am literate enough
to understand whether or not other readers will be able to appreciate the book
or if they will have to put on their hip waders to muck their ways through its
poor editing and outright rape of the English language.
Reviewing a book is an awesome
responsibility. As a reviewer, I may unwittingly encourage one to spend their money
or worse, stop someone from reading a life-changing book. It’s not a job I take
lightly, and I would hope that other writers feel the same way.
Lorca Damon is a teacher in a juvenile correctional facility and staff writer for GoodEReader.com. Her first non-fiction title, Autism By Hand, is an Amazon bestseller and her first fiction title, The Earth is for Dancing, was recently published as well. She is also one of the funniest people I know. You should stalk her at
Lorca Damon is a teacher in a juvenile correctional facility and staff writer for GoodEReader.com. Her first non-fiction title, Autism By Hand, is an Amazon bestseller and her first fiction title, The Earth is for Dancing, was recently published as well. She is also one of the funniest people I know. You should stalk her at
Her website: lorcadamon.com
Twitter: @LorcaDamon
Good E-Reader goodereader.com












